Petitions.com

Report a petition

Preservation of the historic platform canopies of Duisburg Main Station

Petitions express opinions. Disagreeing with a petition, or thinking it is pointless, is not grounds for a report, and such reports are closed automatically. Report a petition only if it breaks the law or our Community Guidelines, for example hate speech, defamation of a person or organisation, publishing private information, or fraud. We do not check whether the claims in a petition are true; the author is responsible for them.

This report goes to the people who run this website, not to the petition author or to any authority. If you have a question or feedback for the author, send them a message.

Why are you reporting this?
What is wrong with the name?
Please tell us in the text field below what makes you think so.

Petitions express opinions. Disagreeing with a petition, or thinking it is pointless, is not grounds for a report, and we do not remove petitions because people oppose them.

If you send this, your disagreement is recorded and the report is closed automatically with no action; the decision is sent to your email address. If the content breaks the law or our Community Guidelines, choose that option above instead.

You can also start your own petition or contact the author.

Is the false claim about you, your organisation, or another identifiable person or organisation?

Which passage is false? You can click several sentences in the petition text, and tell us for each what is true. This is optional.

Sentences next to each other are joined into one claim. Click a sentence again to remove it.

Preservation of the historic platform canopies of Duisburg Main Station

In the context of an investment program for the modernization of railway stations in North Rhine-Westphalia, Deutsche Bahn AG announced its intention to demolish the Duisburger Gleishallen built in steel skeleton construction from 1931-34 with floating roofs without pillars - even for today's conditions a Masterpiece of architecture - and thus ensure accessibility.

In their place a wave-shaped roof construction is to be built, which would be a step backwards from its predecessor, because the roofs in this design are once again conventionally supported by parallel-round pillars or columns.

The question is whether, with the demolition of a major cultural monument, public money will be misused instead of using it for restoration?

The petition therefore calls for a stop and a revision of the plans.

State subsidies from the federal government and the state for the modernization campaign to renew railway stations in NRW should not be used for the demolition of architectural monuments. Rather, it should be sought in a constructive and compromise-oriented way to preserve all or part of the historic platform canopies of Duisburg Main Station, and to revise the plans in cooperation with Deutsche Bahn AG and the relevant ministries and expert inspections.

In the case of the implementation of the DB AG plan for a new roof in Duisburg, the whole cost is € 1 billion for the renewal of 150 railway stations in NRW, in which the federal state is involved with more than 300 million euros - according to a press report the total cost in Duisburg would amount to 150 million euros - a significant piece of architectural history will be lost, as at the moment there is no desire to recognize at least part or one of the platform basilicas there - equipped with filigree and elegant clerestory windows, which guarantee a natural light incidence, and side ships for the entering and exiting trains - from the time of the Classical Modernism of the outgoing Weimar Republic, for posterity and future generations as a vivid and sensible experience of the architectural history. A piece of world cultural heritage would thus be irretrievably lost by the still recent history of station architecture.

The petition does not argue against new projects, but in the opinion of the authors it would be important to consider where - even aesthetically sophisticated - new buildings could be constructed. Since extensive refurbishment and modernization measures are planned for Dortmund's main station, and the platform roofing there is not as extraordinary as their older Duisburger "sisters", the new Wellendach (wave roof) would surely represent an architectural enrichment there and the history of the station building chronologically updating, without the vividness and clarity of historical places to discard, as it offers the Route Industrial Culture in the Ruhr area with the historic track halls.

With appropriate design concepts and with the participation of craftsmen and freelance artists, the Duisburger platform canopies of 1931/34 could become a magnet not only for architects from all over the world, but also provide the citizens of Duisburg with sufficient reason, with self-respect and appreciation of their own history and culture, that means the architectural achievements of their forefathers and mothers, who have created urban centers of entrepreneurial diversity - including the diversity of forms - from a formerly agrarian region.

In this retrospective sense, the petition presented here asks the deputies of the State of North-Rhine Westphalia and the state government of NRW as well as the federal government to take the prioritization of the modernization campaign of Deutsche Bahn AG, in which the state of North Rhine-Westphalia and the federal government participate with large sums. They are requested to consider their responsibility towards the history of the building construction and the protection of monuments and to submit to Deutsche Bahn AG alternative and compromise proposals as outlined here.

It is about nothing less than the preservation of the cultural heritage and the saving of the diversity of forms as a source of inspiration and an innovation engine for future generations.

We would like to thank all the supporters and co-authors of this petition!

Their signatures are a public confession and call for a more conscious and constructive approach to history, combined with the demand for politics and administration, for more dialogue, discourse, participation and democratic co-determination.

If, for various reasons, a population majority is not aware of the historical qualities of craftsmanship and building culture and is not interested in it, and politicians, ministers and planning staffs refer to these "majorities" in their actions, which take advantage of the misery and the lack of interest in general and special educational questions, one can already speak of unconscious decisions. This petition takes position.

Hearty and thoughtful greetings!

Group form & concept

Signed, W.-D. Haberland, Elaine Emile and Dieter Dreipaß

Metropole Ruhr, NRW, Germany, February 18, 2017

Weblinks:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duisburg_Hauptbahnhof

http://www.route-industriekultur.ruhr/themenrouten/03-duisburg-industriekultur-am-rhein/hauptbahnhof-duisburg.html

https://www.land.nrw/de/300-millionen-euro-fuer-die-modernisierung-von-nordrhein-westfalens-bahnhoefen

https://bauprojekte.deutschebahn.com/p/duisburg-hbf

http://www.waz.de/staedte/duisburg/duisburger-hauptbahnhof-bekommt-bis-2022-glaeserne-welle-id12172692.html

Information and pictures of the demolition of historical city districts (so-called "management of the city" since 2002) in Duisburg:

http://bruckhausen.blogspot.de/

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stadtumbau

We do not check whether the claims in a petition are true; the author is responsible for them. If you send this, it is recorded and the report is closed automatically with no action; the decision is sent to your email address.

You can start your own petition with the information you believe is correct, or contact the author.

A false claim about an identifiable person or organisation is defamation, and we do act on that.

Continue: report defamation

Who is the content about?
Is the person the content is about a politician, a decision-maker or another public figure?
What does the content criticise?

Public criticism of how a politician or decision-maker acts in a public role is allowed, also when the events are old. That a matter is old is not in itself a ground for removal. We can still act on a false claim about the person or on otherwise unlawful content.

If the matter is old or no longer current, it is best to contact the petition author directly. The author can remove the petition for any reason; we cannot.

Is the person the content is about a politician, a decision-maker or another public figure?
What does the content criticise?

Public criticism of how a politician or decision-maker acts in a public role is allowed, also when the events are old. That a matter is old is not in itself a ground for removal. We can still act on a false claim about the person or on otherwise unlawful content.

If the matter is old or no longer current, it is best to contact the petition author directly. The author can remove the petition for any reason; we cannot.

We do not check whether the claims in a petition are true; the author is responsible for them. We act on a false claim when it concerns an identifiable person or organisation. If you simply disagree with the claim, you can start your own petition or contact the author.

Click the false sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly is hate speech? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly calls for violence? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly glorifies or incites terrorism? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly harasses or bullies someone? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly reveals private information? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly accuses someone of a crime? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly calls for the death penalty or torture? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Sentences next to each other are joined into one claim. Click a sentence again to remove it.

Preservation of the historic platform canopies of Duisburg Main Station

In the context of an investment program for the modernization of railway stations in North Rhine-Westphalia, Deutsche Bahn AG announced its intention to demolish the Duisburger Gleishallen built in steel skeleton construction from 1931-34 with floating roofs without pillars - even for today's conditions a Masterpiece of architecture - and thus ensure accessibility.

In their place a wave-shaped roof construction is to be built, which would be a step backwards from its predecessor, because the roofs in this design are once again conventionally supported by parallel-round pillars or columns.

The question is whether, with the demolition of a major cultural monument, public money will be misused instead of using it for restoration?

The petition therefore calls for a stop and a revision of the plans.

State subsidies from the federal government and the state for the modernization campaign to renew railway stations in NRW should not be used for the demolition of architectural monuments. Rather, it should be sought in a constructive and compromise-oriented way to preserve all or part of the historic platform canopies of Duisburg Main Station, and to revise the plans in cooperation with Deutsche Bahn AG and the relevant ministries and expert inspections.

In the case of the implementation of the DB AG plan for a new roof in Duisburg, the whole cost is € 1 billion for the renewal of 150 railway stations in NRW, in which the federal state is involved with more than 300 million euros - according to a press report the total cost in Duisburg would amount to 150 million euros - a significant piece of architectural history will be lost, as at the moment there is no desire to recognize at least part or one of the platform basilicas there - equipped with filigree and elegant clerestory windows, which guarantee a natural light incidence, and side ships for the entering and exiting trains - from the time of the Classical Modernism of the outgoing Weimar Republic, for posterity and future generations as a vivid and sensible experience of the architectural history. A piece of world cultural heritage would thus be irretrievably lost by the still recent history of station architecture.

The petition does not argue against new projects, but in the opinion of the authors it would be important to consider where - even aesthetically sophisticated - new buildings could be constructed. Since extensive refurbishment and modernization measures are planned for Dortmund's main station, and the platform roofing there is not as extraordinary as their older Duisburger "sisters", the new Wellendach (wave roof) would surely represent an architectural enrichment there and the history of the station building chronologically updating, without the vividness and clarity of historical places to discard, as it offers the Route Industrial Culture in the Ruhr area with the historic track halls.

With appropriate design concepts and with the participation of craftsmen and freelance artists, the Duisburger platform canopies of 1931/34 could become a magnet not only for architects from all over the world, but also provide the citizens of Duisburg with sufficient reason, with self-respect and appreciation of their own history and culture, that means the architectural achievements of their forefathers and mothers, who have created urban centers of entrepreneurial diversity - including the diversity of forms - from a formerly agrarian region.

In this retrospective sense, the petition presented here asks the deputies of the State of North-Rhine Westphalia and the state government of NRW as well as the federal government to take the prioritization of the modernization campaign of Deutsche Bahn AG, in which the state of North Rhine-Westphalia and the federal government participate with large sums. They are requested to consider their responsibility towards the history of the building construction and the protection of monuments and to submit to Deutsche Bahn AG alternative and compromise proposals as outlined here.

It is about nothing less than the preservation of the cultural heritage and the saving of the diversity of forms as a source of inspiration and an innovation engine for future generations.

We would like to thank all the supporters and co-authors of this petition!

Their signatures are a public confession and call for a more conscious and constructive approach to history, combined with the demand for politics and administration, for more dialogue, discourse, participation and democratic co-determination.

If, for various reasons, a population majority is not aware of the historical qualities of craftsmanship and building culture and is not interested in it, and politicians, ministers and planning staffs refer to these "majorities" in their actions, which take advantage of the misery and the lack of interest in general and special educational questions, one can already speak of unconscious decisions. This petition takes position.

Hearty and thoughtful greetings!

Group form & concept

Signed, W.-D. Haberland, Elaine Emile and Dieter Dreipaß

Metropole Ruhr, NRW, Germany, February 18, 2017

Weblinks:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duisburg_Hauptbahnhof

http://www.route-industriekultur.ruhr/themenrouten/03-duisburg-industriekultur-am-rhein/hauptbahnhof-duisburg.html

https://www.land.nrw/de/300-millionen-euro-fuer-die-modernisierung-von-nordrhein-westfalens-bahnhoefen

https://bauprojekte.deutschebahn.com/p/duisburg-hbf

http://www.waz.de/staedte/duisburg/duisburger-hauptbahnhof-bekommt-bis-2022-glaeserne-welle-id12172692.html

Information and pictures of the demolition of historical city districts (so-called "management of the city" since 2002) in Duisburg:

http://bruckhausen.blogspot.de/

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stadtumbau

Click the false sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly is hate speech? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly reveals private information? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Which passage exactly is terrorist or extremist content? Click the sentences in the petition text.

Sentences next to each other are joined into one claim. Click a sentence again to remove it.

Preservation of the historic platform canopies of Duisburg Main Station

In the context of an investment program for the modernization of railway stations in North Rhine-Westphalia, Deutsche Bahn AG announced its intention to demolish the Duisburger Gleishallen built in steel skeleton construction from 1931-34 with floating roofs without pillars - even for today's conditions a Masterpiece of architecture - and thus ensure accessibility.

In their place a wave-shaped roof construction is to be built, which would be a step backwards from its predecessor, because the roofs in this design are once again conventionally supported by parallel-round pillars or columns.

The question is whether, with the demolition of a major cultural monument, public money will be misused instead of using it for restoration?

The petition therefore calls for a stop and a revision of the plans.

State subsidies from the federal government and the state for the modernization campaign to renew railway stations in NRW should not be used for the demolition of architectural monuments. Rather, it should be sought in a constructive and compromise-oriented way to preserve all or part of the historic platform canopies of Duisburg Main Station, and to revise the plans in cooperation with Deutsche Bahn AG and the relevant ministries and expert inspections.

In the case of the implementation of the DB AG plan for a new roof in Duisburg, the whole cost is € 1 billion for the renewal of 150 railway stations in NRW, in which the federal state is involved with more than 300 million euros - according to a press report the total cost in Duisburg would amount to 150 million euros - a significant piece of architectural history will be lost, as at the moment there is no desire to recognize at least part or one of the platform basilicas there - equipped with filigree and elegant clerestory windows, which guarantee a natural light incidence, and side ships for the entering and exiting trains - from the time of the Classical Modernism of the outgoing Weimar Republic, for posterity and future generations as a vivid and sensible experience of the architectural history. A piece of world cultural heritage would thus be irretrievably lost by the still recent history of station architecture.

The petition does not argue against new projects, but in the opinion of the authors it would be important to consider where - even aesthetically sophisticated - new buildings could be constructed. Since extensive refurbishment and modernization measures are planned for Dortmund's main station, and the platform roofing there is not as extraordinary as their older Duisburger "sisters", the new Wellendach (wave roof) would surely represent an architectural enrichment there and the history of the station building chronologically updating, without the vividness and clarity of historical places to discard, as it offers the Route Industrial Culture in the Ruhr area with the historic track halls.

With appropriate design concepts and with the participation of craftsmen and freelance artists, the Duisburger platform canopies of 1931/34 could become a magnet not only for architects from all over the world, but also provide the citizens of Duisburg with sufficient reason, with self-respect and appreciation of their own history and culture, that means the architectural achievements of their forefathers and mothers, who have created urban centers of entrepreneurial diversity - including the diversity of forms - from a formerly agrarian region.

In this retrospective sense, the petition presented here asks the deputies of the State of North-Rhine Westphalia and the state government of NRW as well as the federal government to take the prioritization of the modernization campaign of Deutsche Bahn AG, in which the state of North Rhine-Westphalia and the federal government participate with large sums. They are requested to consider their responsibility towards the history of the building construction and the protection of monuments and to submit to Deutsche Bahn AG alternative and compromise proposals as outlined here.

It is about nothing less than the preservation of the cultural heritage and the saving of the diversity of forms as a source of inspiration and an innovation engine for future generations.

We would like to thank all the supporters and co-authors of this petition!

Their signatures are a public confession and call for a more conscious and constructive approach to history, combined with the demand for politics and administration, for more dialogue, discourse, participation and democratic co-determination.

If, for various reasons, a population majority is not aware of the historical qualities of craftsmanship and building culture and is not interested in it, and politicians, ministers and planning staffs refer to these "majorities" in their actions, which take advantage of the misery and the lack of interest in general and special educational questions, one can already speak of unconscious decisions. This petition takes position.

Hearty and thoughtful greetings!

Group form & concept

Signed, W.-D. Haberland, Elaine Emile and Dieter Dreipaß

Metropole Ruhr, NRW, Germany, February 18, 2017

Weblinks:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duisburg_Hauptbahnhof

http://www.route-industriekultur.ruhr/themenrouten/03-duisburg-industriekultur-am-rhein/hauptbahnhof-duisburg.html

https://www.land.nrw/de/300-millionen-euro-fuer-die-modernisierung-von-nordrhein-westfalens-bahnhoefen

https://bauprojekte.deutschebahn.com/p/duisburg-hbf

http://www.waz.de/staedte/duisburg/duisburger-hauptbahnhof-bekommt-bis-2022-glaeserne-welle-id12172692.html

Information and pictures of the demolition of historical city districts (so-called "management of the city" since 2002) in Duisburg:

http://bruckhausen.blogspot.de/

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stadtumbau

We use this to acknowledge your report and to tell you the outcome.
I am reporting
What are you asking for? You can choose more than one.
May we forward your request to the petition author? The author can remove the petition for any reason, and may respond to the request sooner than our moderators.
May we forward your request to the petition author? The author can remove the petition for any reason, and may respond to the request sooner than our moderators.
May we forward your request to the petition author? The author can remove the petition for any reason, and may respond to the request sooner than our moderators.

Reported petitions are reviewed by our team to determine if they violate our Terms of Service or Community Guidelines.