Petitions.com

REQUEST for SPOONFLOWER to ADDRESS A.I. CHEATING

To the Spoonflower Corporation and CEO: We, the undersigned, representing the Spoonflower community of graphic designers and illustrators, who have invested of our time, money and efforts to produce original, human-made work to sell in Spoonflower shops, are calling for the Spoonflower corporation to honor our existence as artists as outlined below.  

We applaud and recognize the steps that Spoonflower has made in moderating the weekly challenges for Artificial-intelligence generative art. However, as Spoonflower and other Print-on-Demand sites are being inundated with a.i. by a proliferation of new and existing shops, we are requesting more stringent oversight.

1. CLEARLY STATED RULES WITH CONSEQUENCES should be written with a check-box on the challenge-entry page. Currently the rule against a.i. art is buried in the fine print, and it is hard to hold people accountable if they can pretend they never saw the rule. ADDING A CHECK BOX WITH A SCREEN GRAB OR PROOF OF WORK IN PROGRESS WOULD BE AN EASY WAY TO VET ENTRIES. 

2. CHEATERS SHOULD BE BLOCKED FOR 3-6 MONTHS, if not permanently.  This would help your staff immensely because the amount of repeat offenders is growing by the week, undermining our earning potential and integrity.  Blocking them would minimize the work for your staff.

3. REMOVE PAST A.I. ENTRIES FROM KNOWN CHEATERS FROM CHALLENGE RESULTS. Past cheaters continually benefit from the hearts/ likes and wins of designs that they did not personally make. We can provide lists of past generative designs that are still in the top 50 lists from the last year.

4. IF POSSIBLE, REMOVE OR REDUCE THE HEARTS on known past challenge entries so that search engine algorithms do not continue to benefit cheaters.  If you still allow these a.i. generated images to be sold in the shops, that is at your discretion, but at the very least they should not be allowed to capitalize on their unscrupulous prior challenge-wins to get better visibility. It’s a huge disservice to everyone that works so hard to be noticed by customers.

Imagine Olympic medalists using performance enhancing drugs, and the Olympic committees allowing them to keep their medals and world records because it had “already happened.” It would be a disgrace to athletics. Likewise, these people using a.i. to gain unmerited placement is a disgrace to all of us who put in hours and hours each week to create new designs for Spoonflower customers to purchase.

At best, generative art looks “fine,” but is derived from established designers, many of them already on Spoonflower (and we have screen grabs proving the malicious intent to mimic the work of their peers). At worst, it’s laughably bad patterns with poor “repeats” or misshapen details, (such as animals with extra legs or eyeballs). Ideally, a.i. would be completely blocked from your website,  but for now the cheating needs to have consequences.  When customers start complaining about this lack of quality control perhaps you will be forced to remove those designs. But meanwhile, the a.i. keeps improving and now there are designs that are nearly indistinguishable from hand-painted motifs. The only evidence is the screen grabs from sites like Midjourney.

Spoonflower-related social-media communities are buzzing with talk against a.i.  We urge you to consider our requests in a judicious and quick manner before your own reputation hangs in the balance.

Sincerely, The 100% Human Made design-coalition