Суд над Бхагавад-гитой / Attempt to ban Bhagavad-gita

Contact the author of the petition

This discussion topic has been automatically created of petition Суд над Бхагавад-гитой / Attempt to ban Bhagavad-gita.


Guest

#426

2011-12-17 06:54

Yes, in the Bhagavad-gita there are encouragements for violence. That is undeniable. But one have to consider also the following points to see everything in context.

1. All the reasons that lead to the decision to get into war as described in the Mahabharata.
2. Krishna's instructions to fight were very personal to Arjuna who was a soldier.
a. One could fight nowadays only if personally instructed by God, Krishna.
b. Using only the scripture like the Bhagavad-gita as a reason to fight would be completely wrong.
3. With the advancement of the age of spiritual degradation there are more and more people who are violent and angry on all religions. If religious people would like to kill all of them that would mean more than 20% of the world's population would have to be killed. That is not practical nor good.
a. The human form of life is considered very valuable for attainment of enlightenment and self-realization. The true followers of the Bhagavad-gita know this and so they would not kill anybody but rather try to teach the science of yoga and self-realization as explained in the Gita.
b. With the advent of Caitanya Mahaprabhu the above point is even more emphasized. "Help others to attain love of God rather than kill them because they are irreligious."

For the end one remark. There are studies published on the internet that explain how the Bible is more violence encouraging than the Koran. So the question could be, why not ban the Bible and the Koran as well? But no scriptures have to be banned if violent statement are understood in context of time place and circumstances and the above points mentioned.

Seeing the ultimate goal of Bhagavad gita, the development of all good spiritual qualities and the attainment of spiritual perfection in human life-form, the attempt of those who desire to ban the Gita is ridiculous. Obviously motivated with pride, desire for control and prestige they are not interested in such perfection. May Lord Krishna enlighten them so that they understand: THEY ARE DOING SOMETHING REALLY WRONG.


Guest

#427

2011-12-17 06:57

Кали-юга.Мозги отсутствуют.

Guest

#428

2011-12-17 06:57

I fully agree with this petition & wish that those who want to ban the most important & most populer book in the world will realize their mistake.
If they do not & the book is banned, India should cut off all diplomatic relations with Russia because Bhagahavd Gita means India & by condeming Bhagavad Gita, they are condeming entire India

Guest

#429

2011-12-17 06:59

Бхагават-Гита это книга благодаря которой я стал человеком.

Guest

#430

2011-12-17 07:01

Какая глупость. Что дальше будет?

Guest

#431

2011-12-17 07:01

СУД НАД БХАГАВАТ-ГИТОЙ,ЭТО БЕСПРИНЦИПНЫЙ АКТ НАШЕЙ ЭПОХИ!!!!

Guest

#432

2011-12-17 07:02

Этот суд - это просто темнота невежества. КАК можно судить слова Бога? Тогда может быть нужно судить небо, облака (за то, что льют не тогда, когда нам хочется), землю (за то, что не дает урожай в том количестве, которое нас устраивает), солнце (за то, что устраивает магнитные бури...), и многое другое. Видимо, люди, затеявшие суд, нуждаются в помощи психиатра. Следовало бы лицам, занимающим ответственные посты, периодически проходить медосмотр у психиатра.

Guest

#433

2011-12-17 07:03

Bhagvad Gita is science of soul. Mahatma Gandhi always use to keep one with him & refer to it whenever he did not find answers to his problems. Has there been a person more peacr loving than him ? This is the effect Bhagvad Gita has on people.In fact it is the only soultion against violence.

Guest

#434

2011-12-17 07:03

Харе Кришна!!

Guest

#435

2011-12-17 07:04

Stop this!!

Guest

#436

2011-12-17 07:05

Bhagavad Gita contains non sectarian words of wisdom and it should be made available to all humans. Trying to ban this literature is a cruel act and it should be stopped.

Guest

#437

2011-12-17 07:05

Thise book is veri veri nice!

Guest

#438

2011-12-17 07:06

Степаненко, Шитик и Аванесов должны сеть в тюрьму как лица, распространяющуи клевету, бестыже врущие перед народом и судом, а так же за личные оскорбления в адрес тех кого они называют сектантами и за подстрекательство к межнациональной и межрелигиозной розне. таким людям место не в Церкви, а на нарах.

Guest

#439

2011-12-17 07:06

Love thy neighbor as thyself

Guest

#440

2011-12-17 07:07

Please prevent this attrosity, it is an insult to billions of people who are following tbis literature.

Guest

#441

2011-12-17 07:08

I am sure Russian people will all also agree with this petition that Bhagavad Gita should not be banned.
We pray to all Russians , pl. ask your govt to intervene & stop this persuction.
Мандала Пати даса

#442 Re:

2011-12-17 07:10

#14: -

ТА СОРОМ!!!!!

 


Guest

#443

2011-12-17 07:12

father forgive them for they know not what they do

Guest

#444

2011-12-17 07:13

Hare Krishna! Bhagavat-gita Djaia :)

Guest

#445

2011-12-17 07:13

Pleeeeease. This is a holy book revered by over a billion people worldwide. How can you even think of banning this. please read the book and then decide what you'd want to do. thanks

Guest

#446

2011-12-17 07:14

I hope Lord Krishna will give brain to all those who wants to Ban.

Guest

#447

2011-12-17 07:15

Философия Бхагавад гиты (перевод и комментарии Шрилы Прабхупады) изменила мою жизнь и меняет её по сей день только в лучшую сторону. Для нашей страны и мира в целом, которые погрязли в пьянстве и наркомании, эта литература является спасением, а не угрозой.

Guest

#448

2011-12-17 07:15

Bhagavad Gita is a holy scripture and it propagates peace, kindness and non-violence. It's non-sense to ban it!

Guest

#449

2011-12-17 07:17

подтверждаю подпись под петицией

Guest

#450

2011-12-17 07:17

The Russian government is atheistic, conceited, arrogant and demonic. They want to stay in control of the public, and think that by ignoring the existence of God that He won't exist. They don't care about the truth, but only want to advance their own ridiculous concocted theories about life. Their only interest is money and power.